艾滋病诊断书不是“免死金牌”

艾滋病诊断书不是“免死金牌”

 
 
 
 
 

艾滋病诊断书不是“免死金牌”

2009-05-24 12:28:50
来源:北国网- 半岛晨报

  □杨国栋

  艾滋病不是免罚通行证,人性化执法也不等于法外开恩。以对方是艾滋病人为由取消处罚不仅算不上人性化执法,反而有失职之嫌。

  一河南籍司机戴某驾大货车满载焦炭从河南前往上海,到达沪宁高速河阳收费站时,民警发现货车超载大约15%。当民警要其出示证件时,戴某却递出了一张艾滋病诊断书,称自己患有艾滋病。

  民警严肃地告诉他,艾滋病不是免罚通行证,但考虑戴某患有艾滋病,且交法规定超载10%之内可免处罚,戴某超载额度不大,最终决定免予处罚。

  虽然戴某患有艾滋病,值得同情,但这并不是民警可以对其违法行为免予处罚的依据。

  从报道看,戴某下车后,主动拿出自己的艾滋病诊断书给民警看,说明他是有意识地利用艾滋病人的特殊身份来逃避处罚,而且很可能不是第一次这么干了。

  近年来,艾滋病人利用自己的特殊身份来逃避行政处罚甚至进行违法犯罪,早已不是什么新鲜事。广东东莞许多医院今年就遭到众多艾滋病感染者的勒索,这些人手持艾滋病检测报告,声称“不给钱,就咬人”。

  出于对艾滋病的恐惧或是对艾滋病人的同情,很多执法部门在处理涉及艾滋病人的违法犯罪行为时,往往会网开一面,甚至根本不作任何处罚。

  这种做法无形中助长了一些艾滋病人的侥幸心理,使他们更加肆无忌弹。

  沈阳一名艾滋病人在街坊邻居间四处敲诈,屡次以“不给钱,就杀人”威胁邻居。连民警都不敢抓他,反被他追着跑。终于,在用武力威胁一名贫困的擦鞋匠时,反被擦鞋匠夺刀砍死。造成这一悲剧固然有当事者自己的原因,但警方之前的不作为显然难辞其咎。

  艾滋病不是免罚通行证,人性化执法也不等于法外开恩。以对方是艾滋病人为由取消处罚不仅算不上人性化执法,反而有失职之嫌。另外,手持艾滋病诊断书的并不一定真的是艾滋病人。

  很多地方都出现过手持伪造的艾滋病检测报告、艾滋病诊断书(或是他人的检测报告、诊断书)来敲诈或逃避处罚的事。如果警方对此类行为不加干预,也许不久后,艾滋病检测报告或艾滋病诊断书就会成为街头混混、惯偷、劫匪们的“绿色通行证”,而货运司机也会把艾滋病诊断书当成避免违章处罚的“免死金牌”。A02c

AIDS diagnosis is not "免死金牌"
2009-05-24 12:28:50
Source: Bei Guo Net - Peninsula Morning News
□ Yang

AIDS is not a laissez-passer penalty-free, humane law enforcement does not mean that things mercy. To the other side is a man-made AIDS is not only not punished by the deletion of the enforcement of human nature, but are suspected of dereliction of duty.

A Henan戴某drivers who drive big trucks loaded with coke from Henan Province to Shanghai, the Shanghai-Nanjing high-speed hayang arrive at the toll booths, the police found about 15% of overloading of goods vehicles. When the police to produce their documents when they戴某delivery of a diagnosis of AIDS, saying they are suffering from AIDS.

Police told him seriously, AIDS is not a penalty-free passes, but戴某suffering from AIDS, law and pay 10 percent of overloading to avoid punishment, not the amount of overloading戴某, the final decision to exempt from punishment.

Although戴某suffering from AIDS, deserve our sympathy, but their offense is not the police can be the basis for exemption from punishment.

From the reports, the戴某get off and take the initiative to come up with their own look at AIDS diagnosis to the police shows that he is conscious use of the special status of persons living with AIDS to avoid punishment, but not the first time are likely to do so.

In recent years, AIDS patients use their special status to avoid administrative penalties or even criminal, are nothing new. Dongguan in Guangdong this year, many hospitals have been many AIDS extortion, armed with these people AIDS testing report, claiming that "no money, they bite."

AIDS out of fear or sympathy for AIDS, many law enforcement agencies in dealing with AIDS when criminal acts are often spared, and even does not make any punishment.

This is virtually a number of AIDS contributed to the idea of trusting to luck and made them even more unscrupulous shells.

Shenyang, an AIDS among people everywhere neighbors blackmail, repeated "not money, on the homicide," a threat to neighbors. Even the police are afraid to grasp him by his anti-chasing run. Finally, the threat of the use of force in the rubbing of a poor shoemaker, the anti-seize was knifed dead rubbed shoemaker. While this tragedy has caused the parties own reasons, but not before the police as apparently to blame.

AIDS is not a laissez-passer penalty-free, humane law enforcement does not mean that things mercy. To the other side is a man-made AIDS is not only not punished by the deletion of the enforcement of human nature, but are suspected of dereliction of duty. In addition, the holding of the AIDS diagnosis is not necessarily true of AIDS.

Many places there have been armed with the report of false detection of AIDS, AIDS medical certificate (or other people's testing report, medical certificate) to blackmail or to avoid punishment thing. If the police conduct of such intervention, perhaps not long after the detection of AIDS or AIDS will become the street want a medical certificate,惯偷, the robbers were "green pass", while the freight drivers will be treated as a medical certificate to avoid AIDS illegal punishment "免死金牌." A02c
 
 
 
 
 

[ 作者:佚名    转贴自:本站原创    点击数:197    更新时间:2009-5-24    文章录入:nnb ]

 

个人简介
协和专家门诊部艾滋病治疗中心主任、教授、专家,中医药疑难病专治网站长等。论文《艾滋病中医论治探析》登载《中国性病艾滋病》2003版杂志,发明的艾滋病治疗新药康生丹自2002年临床应用至今疗效显著,现有中国唯一艾滋病新药3代…
每日关注 更多
赞助商广告